When you think of campfires, you probably think of roasting marshmallows and making s’mores.
While these are delicious, it’s fun to try something different and take your campfire delicacies to the next level by using a campfire sandwich maker.
Just imagine how delicious hot toasted bread and melted cheese on chilly nights will be, and best of all you can still make your beloved s’mores with it.
Don’t you need electricity to use a sandwich maker? No!
The campfire sandwich makers we’re talking about involve smart and creative ways to make sandwiches right over the fire in really easy ways.
Campfire sandwich makers come in a variety of styles and boast different features that make them stand out in a crowd, but one of the best is the Toas-Tite Sandwich Grill because you can make sandwiches and pies with it.
It’s perfect for you if you’re a culinary king or queen but it’s still user-friendly for beginners. Let’s check it out in more detail in this guide to the best campfire sandwich maker: enjoy delicious sammies around the campfire.
Best Overall Winner: Toas-Tite Sandwich Grill
- Size: 15.5 x 4.75 x 1.5 inches (39 x 12 x 3.81 cm)
- Weight: 0.07 lbs (31 g)
- Length: 15.5 inches (39 cm)
- This campfire sandwich maker allows you to make a ton of delicious cheap snacks on the fire, such as toasted sandwiches, omelets, s’mores, popcorn, grilled cheese, and more. This makes it so versatile because you’ll be able to turn your campfire into a kitchen without any other tools or appliances at your disposal.
- It’s got a nostalgic appearance because it’s a replica of the 1949 original Toas-Tite, but you’ll also love that it’s made with strong cast aluminum, steel rods, and hardwood handles to make it modern and durable.
- It’s versatile enough to be used on gas, glass-top stoves, in the fireplace or fire pit, or on your BBQ grill. This means that whatever cooking conditions you’re dealing with on vacation, you’ll be able to use your campfire sandwich maker.
- Not only can you make sandwiches you and your family love, but since the Toas-Tite comes with a sealed edge you don’t have to worry about not being able to enjoy sandwiches and pies that have yummy fillings. No more boring sandwiches on holiday!
- The handle of this campfire sandwich maker is a bit short – coming in at only nine inches – so you have to be careful not to burn yourself when using it. If this is a dealbreaker for you and you want a campfire sandwich maker that has a longer handle, move on to the runner-up product in our list of reviews.
- Some people who purchased this sandwich maker in Amazon have reported that it sometimes causes leaks and spills. This can be prevented by ensuring that you don’t overstuff your sandwiches and pies.
- This is not just a sandwich maker – it’s a trip down memory lane as it’s sure to bring back memories of your childhood if your mother or grandmother used the original Toas-Tite. This makes it a wonderful thing to let your children experience, and what better time than when you’re enjoying a camping holiday together?
The Toas-Tite campfire sandwich maker will make it easy for you to feel like you can enjoy tasty homemade sandwiches and pies even when you’re not in your home kitchen.
You can make food to take with you on hikes or just enjoy when you’re huddled around the fire. If you want a Toas-Tite with a longer handle, you can choose the XL-handle option before adding the product to your cart.
Runner Up: Coleman Camp Cooker
- Size: 4.75 x 1.38 x 24.63 inches (12 x 3.5 x 60 cm)
- Weight: 1.15 pounds (521 g)
- Length: 4.75 inches (12 cm)
- This Coleman Camp cooker also toasts sandwiches but it can grill meat over the fire. It’s so versatile, you could even use it to make pizza-inspired sandwiches, so if you love being creative in the kitchen or at the campfire this sandwich maker is a must to purchase. You’ll be able to bring your favorite foods from home to your holiday destination.
- It’s got a non-stick surface that’s extremely easy to clean, so you won’t have to worry about washing up when you’re on vacation.
- This toast sandwich maker is made out of durable and strong cast aluminum. This means you’ll be able to take it with you on a variety of camping trips without worrying about it giving up on you when you really need it.
- It comes with a hinge that you can use to keep the foods you want to toast securely in place, making this campfire sandwich maker really easy to use and preventing spills in the process. One of the things that puts me off regular sandwich makers is how they never keep the sandwich filing intact, so this one is a game-changer.
- One of the drawbacks of this sandwich maker is associated with its hinge. Some people who have purchased this sandwich maker have reported that the hinge tends to bend after some time of use, and this prevents it from closing properly.
- The handles are made of metal so they tend to become hot. A plastic or wood covering similar to what is featured on the Toas-Tite would have been a great extra feature to make this campfire sandwich maker user-friendly.
- The basket in which you make the sandwiches is five by five inches and it’s in the shape of a square so it’s perfect for making traditional sammies.
If you’re looking for a campfire sandwich maker that has some extra features to make enjoying grilled snacks on holiday even more convenient, such as a long handle, then this pocket sandwich maker is the one for you because its handle is 17.6 inches in length. It’s also much more affordable than the previous product we featured.
Alternative 1: Old Mountain Sandwich Pie Iron
- Size: 28.5 x 4.5 x 1.75 inches (72 x 11 x 4.44 cm)
- Weight: 2.5 pounds (1,133 g)
- Length: 28.5 inches (72 cm)
- This Old Mountain sandwich pie iron looks ready for the task of making delicious toasted sandwiches over the campfire: it has a solid hinged design and genuine wood handles to make using it much easier. These touches also make it look well-constructed.
- You can remove the handles so that you can store this sandwich maker in your backpack much more conveniently. This campfire sandwich maker is therefore the most convenient and portable on the market, especially if you’re running out of space in your bag.
- If you’re like me, you want to be able to fill your pies with lots of messy fillings, and this sandwich maker enables me to do that because of how it pinches the bread together so that the filling stays in place. This produces hearty, delicious pies and you won’t have a big job having to clean up later.
- Some people who have purchased this campfire sandwich maker have reported that it tends to rust. You’re going to have to be careful with it and make sure you wipe it down after use and store it in a dry place.
- Although this campfire sandwich maker is built to be durable and sturdy, people have reported that it feels a bit flimsy and loose when handled. This, however, isn’t said to get in the way of making delicious sandwiches over the fire.
- It’s the ideal size for standard bread, which means you won’t have to try to find bread that fits – or spend a lot of time cutting bread slices to size. That also means less time cooking and more time enjoying the food with your loved ones.
If you want pies filled with creamy and delicious fillings, this Old Mountain sandwich pie iron is the best sandwich maker to buy.
However, if you want a campfire sandwich maker that has a similar design to this one but is much cheaper, then you’ll want to consider the next item on our list.
Alternative 2: Texsport Cast Iron Square Pie Sandwich Maker
- Size: 29 x 4 x 2 inches (73 x 10 x 5 cm)
- Weight: 3.2 pounds (1,451 g)
- Length: 29 inches (73.66 g)
- You don’t want your sammie maker to rust or chip, so you’ll love this one because it’s a pre-seasoned cast iron campfire sandwich maker that’s designed to be tough and durable.
- Cast iron ensures greater heat distribution so that you can get lovely crusts on your bread and pies. I love it when the edges of a sandwich or pie are crusty but the middle is soft and juicy. Delicious!
- If you know a bit about campfire sandwich makers, you’ll have seen that some seal the slices of bread when you make a sandwich while others don’t. This one does a good job sealing them properly.
- Linked to the above point, you can pack your sandwiches with more fillings when using this hot sandwich maker, and that makes this campfire sandwich maker perfect for making pies.
- This sandwich maker is a bit heavy, coming in at around three pounds. This can make them tricky for children to use.
- The top and bottom of this sandwich maker doesn’t come apart. This is an important thing to consider because it can make removing your sandwich or pie from the sandwich maker a bit difficult, and can result in you burning your fingers.
- The material out of which this sandwich maker is built ensures that your bread won’t stick, which serves another great purpose: campfire clean-up will be so much easier. You also won’t end up with a mess all over your stove if you’re using this sandwich maker at home or in an outdoor kitchen.
This Texsport campfire sandwich is cost-effective and durable enough to use again and again. If you want to ensure a stick-free sandwich-making experience, it’s definitely worth purchasing. It’s the most value-for-money campfire sandwich maker.
Best Gas Stove Sandwich Maker: Yakime ga Saku Saku SJ2408 Hot Sandwich Maker
- Size: 15.12 x 6.3 x 1.5 inches (38 x 16 x 3.8 cm)
- Weight: 13.4 ounces (379 g)
- Length: 15.12 inches (38 cm)
- This sandwich maker is made out of aluminum alloy. This makes it strong. Aluminum alloy has an excellent high-tensile strength and resists impact very well, which increases the sandwich maker’s lifespan.
- It comes with a non-stick coating and grill lines so you’ll feel like the crispy toasted sandwiches you make during your camping holiday are just like the ones you make at home.
- It’s really easy to clean. Although you can’t put it in the dishwasher, it has a fluoride coating that makes it easy to remove stains. The sandwich maker also disassembles so that you can clean its parts easily.
- This sandwich maker can’t be used on an electric stove.
- The pan is a little thin which can cause your toasted sandwiches to burn if you’re not careful with it.
- By being able to make toasted sandwiches on a stovetop, you avoid having to use a pan, which you know can be difficult and prevent you from achieving evenly-toasted bread or having a perfectly sealed sandwich. That’s what you’ll easily achieve with this sandwich maker.
This metal campfire sandwich can be tucked away into a drawer or your backpack and whipped out when you’re cooking with gas, ensuring that you and your family can have tasty toasted sandwiches wherever you are. While it offers quality cooking, it’s also really friendly to your camping holiday budget.
Campfire Sandwich Maker FAQ
Now that we’ve looked at the best campfire sandwich maker to make the tastiest snacks during your camping holidays, along with four alternatives to consider, let’s look at information you need to make the best use of your sandwich maker so that the food you make around the campfire will be delicious every single time.
How to use sandwich maker
It’s really easy to use a sandwich maker, and campfire sandwich makers are even simpler to use because you don’t have to plug them in.
First, you’ll want to prepare your slices of bread by buttering them on both sides (this will ensure that they don’t stick), then you can fill them with ingredients, such as cheese.
Open the sandwich maker and place the sandwich in the campfire maker’s basket – this is the round or square piece at the end of the handles that holds the sandwich in place while you toast it over the fire.
Some campfire sandwich makers will have clips or hinges to secure your pie or sandwich so that it can be toasted evenly.
An example is the Coleman Camp Cooker that has a hinge and this also serves the purpose of making it easy to use the sandwich maker, even when you’re holding it over a fire.
How do you open a sandwich maker?
A campfire sandwich maker will have two parts that join together. When you’ve prepared your sandwiches, you’ll place a slice of bread on one side of the maker and the other on the other side.
Then you’ll connect the sandwich iron’s sides together and press the sandwich down. You’ll also have to lock the handles together – these sandwich makers will usually have a clasp or hinge that will enable you to do this.
Then, when the sandwich has been cooked properly, you will open it by moving the handles and unlocking the clasp. Some sandwich makers don’t allow you to let both sides come apart to remove your sandwich, so you have to be extra careful when removing them.
If your sandwiches are a little wider than the sandwich maker’s dimensions, a good tip is to snip off the excess bread while the sandwich is still inside the sandwich maker with the use of a knife. This will make it easier plus give you neater sandwich edges.
Can you cook eggs or bacon or other foods in a sandwich maker?
You can cook eggs in a variety of ways with a campfire sandwich maker, such as in the form of omelettes or French toast. You might even be able to cook a fried egg.
This, as well as cooking bacon and other foods, can be done in a regular sandwich maker, however you might battle a little when using a campfire sandwich maker because of how much smaller it is than a standard kitchen sandwich maker. That doesn’t mean you shouldn’t go ahead and try, though!
How do you clean a sandwich maker after use?
It’s always a good idea to clean your sandwich maker after every time you use it to prevent greasy build-up. You can easily do this even when you’re on a camping vacation simply by removing the plates and washing them in a bit of soapy water.
If the type of sandwich maker you have doesn’t allow you to remove its plates, you’ll have to take a bit more time to clean it. You might also have to pick off some dry food with a plastic spatula.
To make cleaning your campfire sandwich maker even easier, plan ahead by buying a maker that prevents sticking. An example is the Coleman Camp cooker that has a non-stick surface. Less sticking means less cleaning up afterwards!
How long should a campfire sandwich maker be?
One of the most important features you’ll want to look out for when purchasing a campfire sandwich maker is the length of its handles. The longer the handles, the easier it will be to hold over a fire without feeling like you’re getting too close to the heat.
Generally, a toast sandwich maker that has a handle length of around 14 or 15 inches or longer will be sufficient. The Coleman Camp sandwich maker has a handle that’s 17.6 inches in length, which is what makes it such a stand-out product.
Our favorite campfire sandwich maker, the Toas-Tite, comes in at around nine inches in length but you can purchase an XL version of it that gives you 21 inches of handle length, so it’s worth it.
Campfires and sandwiches are a match made in heaven, and even more so when you’ve got the best campfire sandwich maker to help you out.
While there are sandwich makers that will make a variety of sandwiches and pies, such as the Coleman Camp maker, the Toas-Tite maker has extra features you’ll love, such as how its metal handles are covered to prevent them from getting too hot.
You can also use it in a variety of ways, whereas some other quality campfire sandwich makers are a bit more limited. For example, the Yakime ga Saku Saku SJ2408 sandwich maker can’t be used on electric stoves, while the Toas-Tite is a lot more versatile.